“It was easier to say ‘don’t diet, riot!’ when I was a size twelve” (new writing)

January 11, 2013 § 3 Comments


no diet talk

I’m working on a paper that explores feminist approaches to economic justice through the metaphor of that old feminist staple, body image. Economic issues are less well-trodden ground in the feminist canon (with awesome exceptions like Folbre, Waring, Fraser), and I hope to expand my own thinking on economic issues by using some of the wisdom from a more familiar feminist territory, the body.

Sitting on the balcony of a small apartment I share with a friend at university, I drink wine and discuss that feminist staple, body image. The friend I share a drink with is a classic of the student activist scene I belong to: loud, anarchic, bisexual, and, I think, joyously fat. I am naively shocked, therefore, when she tells me that her body shape bothers her: “It was easier to say ‘don’t diet, riot!’ when I was a size twelve”, she states, swigging her beer. The atmosphere becomes confessional. I smile awkwardly at her words, aching with the complexity of it all, and there my memory dissolves into the hazy, warm Newcastle twilight.

My friend’s statement has stayed with me for years. She reminded me that it is easier to make a counter-hegemonic claim when you have no investment in the outcome, and perhaps more importantly, that it is harder to make claims about change to dominant discourses when the counter-hegemonic wisdom does not fit anymore. This is how I felt when I began to wonder, both despite and because of my involvement with trade unions and women’s groups, just why the alternative economic doctrines of social democracy or socialism did not seem to fit anymore. If these doctrines did fit, then their supposed champions were sorely lacking confidence in prosecuting the case. How then, could I fruitfully think about gender and economic change-making, when Stuart Hall’s left melancholy had taken hold with a vengeance? It occurred to me that I was something like a yoyo dieter who could not accept that the old wisdom was not working. I was losing the battle with the weight of the problem of economic inequality, yet I felt compelled to do something – something – to arrest the creeping scales of oppression.

Image is from definatalie’s Flickr photostream, licensed by Creative Commons.

Tagged: , , , ,

§ 3 Responses to “It was easier to say ‘don’t diet, riot!’ when I was a size twelve” (new writing)

  • This is my favorite snippet of writing that I have read of yours. Although I don’t quite agree with the analogy if it is taken too much further though. But as it is just a snippet I can’t tell. Are you going to post the rest?

    • Thanks Michelle. I appreciate your comment. It’s funny timing that you’ve commented on this now, as I submitted the full article to Australian Feminist Studies on the long weekend. I won’t post the rest of it here for that reason, though I could potentially write some more on the subject for this space. I’d be curious to know what you liked about it (the topic, the style, the analogy, something else)? Particularly as it didn’t get much response on the blog when I posted it, which didn’t bother me so much, but I just figured it wasn’t the sort of thing folks wanted to read here. Thanks again.

      • Conversations with wine is where life really begins, long after you think you have already begun living.
        It reads like a book, not a blog post. It doesn’t spark the rage like blogging normally does. Might be why there are less comments.
        But I think sneakily this post reveals more about you than any of the others. You speak more formally, but in many ways it is the most intensely personal of all ur posts I have read so far.
        In two paragraphs you talk about body image, growing up, changing beliefs, being confused, learning new things about friends, being sad, feeling like its hopeless, oppression, ideology, the need for fresh ideas…
        I would be love to read more.
        Congrats on submitting the article to a journal! Super exiting!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading “It was easier to say ‘don’t diet, riot!’ when I was a size twelve” (new writing) at The Filing Cabinet.


%d bloggers like this: